The Crusades - Epilogue
There were many reasons for failure. The chieftains were always quarreling, caring more
for their own interests than for the common cause; all jealous of one another. and fearful
of a success which might promote the influence or fame of a rival; divided, suspicious,
half-hearted effort against a fearless, united people, a race always bold in war, and
under the absolute rule of one commander, whether caliph or sultan. They possessed no
far-sighted vision. They did not realize that to maintain a kingdom in Palestine, a
thousand miles away required constant communication with western Europe, a strong base of
supply, continual reinforcement.
There were some good results. The Crusades did force Europe out of its isolationist shells
and into contact with a new culture, one with such valued products as spices, precious
stones, silks. Because of the lack of refrigeration, most of the meat they ate was either
salted or spoiled, spices made food more edible and left Europeans dissatisfied with their
own products. The Crusades furnished a great impulse to the expansion of trade, in fact
the chief permanent effect of the Crusades in the Near East was in trade. Pilgrims
protected by the Turkish government, and persecution ceased, land became more prosperous;
Moslem aggression checked in the west; better acquaintance of nations with each other,
among nations a mutual respect for each other arose and alliances were formed. The
crusades were a great contribution toward the development of modern Europe.
By the 1280's Crusades had become a purely political institution. The final result, the
vast wealth, the overweening ambition, and the unscrupulous use of power by churchmen,
aroused discontent, and aided to pave the way for the approaching revolt against the Roman
Catholic Church. The crusading idea, of a holy war commanded and blessed by the Church,
had become deeply implanted by the Western European mind. Also waged against the Moslems
in Spain, against pagans, against the heretical Cathari, and against others, some of them
Christian, whom the popes adjudged enemies of the faith. Military orders arose from the
crusades. Their members took the standard vows of poverty, chastity and obedience, but
were warriors who had blindly dedicated their lives and their arms to the service of
Christ. Here arose the Knights of the Sword, the Teutonic Knights, Templars and
Hospitallers. To put it in Augustinian terms, it was the employment of the instruments of
the earthly city to further the City of God.
Gibbon says flatly that "the lives and labors of millions, which were buried in the
east, would have been more profitably employed in the improvement of their native country.
Modern France is the creation of the Crusades. They stimulated commerce, broadened
intellectual horizons, served as an outlet for surplus population, gave peasants status,
provided land for the landless, and were a primary stimulant for bringing Europe out of
feudalism. Although they attracted rogues and adventurers, there were also simple folk who
believed it was God's will that the Holy Land be rescued from the infidels..
The conquest of the land was an intrusion, not a
liberation. The people of Palestine were practically slaves to the crusaders, castles and
fortresses were built for them, and palaces for their hated masters. They welcomed the
return of their former Moslem rulers, for heavy as their yoke had been, it was lighter
than that of the Christian kings of Jerusalem.
[20, 23, 44, 48, 269]
Issue Oriented Discussion Newsletter
Index | Search This Site | Aristide.Org | The Latter Rain | Babylon the Great | The Kingdom | The Nicolaitans | Jezebel
The Baptism With the Holy Ghost | The Grand Delusion | World Trade Org | Liberation Theology | Jay Atkinson | Alphabetical Index